He is listed in the 1869 New York City Directory, living at 7 w 15th, - ancestry.com.
Found him on the 1870 New York, New York census (Dist 16 img 23) as Christian Tenger
age 38. Lager Beer Saloon.
Found him on the 1880 Manhattan, New York census (dist 159 img 21) as Charles Tenger
age 48, Lager bier saloon. Father, mother born Switzerland.